By Michelle Gardiner
•
November 11, 2026
A board only sees what management chooses to show it, and part of the job is knowing when that picture is incomplete. Senior executives gathered in Perth last month for our Pathway to the Boardroom event, where we were joined by John Klepec and Caroline Chan , experienced board directors within the resources, mining, financial services, agribusiness and property industries, on ASX-listed and privately held boards. We revisited some of the ground covered at our recent events, with a closer look at how boards deal with management and why boards should lead on AI. Six key themes stood out. The pathway is not linear Board roles tend to come through your network and being recommended; however, opportunities are few and far between. It is important to be mindful of the board roles you pursue, as conflicts, time commitments and market positioning could prevent you from getting other board roles in the future, but you may need to accept some trade-offs initially. As an aspiring director it is important to set expectations on where you sit in the market, look in the mirror and think about what you are suited for. The transition to board can be quite difficult and it requires a mindset shift. Boards appoint on more than your CV A board is a team sport. You are bound by the collective decision of the board. It is important to have dissenting views on a board, but at the end of the day you have to be as one. Your value proposition is an evolution, and articulating it takes time. The skills on your CV and the industries and roles you have worked in help to form the basis, but those are not necessarily what boards appoint you for. What becomes important is how others assess and take a view on how you might behave in the boardroom when exercising your skills and judgements constructively. Culture shapes performance. Skilled, low-ego directors can be very effective, while a room full of combative personalities is dysfunctional. Start your due diligence with the Chair The most important conversation is with the Chair, and finding out who else you know on the board. The Chair sets the tone, and the way the Chair handles challenges is an important signal of board culture. Decisions bind you collectively and it is very difficult to remove someone from a board, so thorough due diligence is key. Look at how people behave under pressure, because even after due diligence you don’t really know until you work with them. What suits you depends on what you want to get out of it Each type of board asks something different. In a government board there is more emphasis on compliance, public accountability and policy expectations. In a private organisation, shareholder’s objectives shape the agenda. Private boards can be very good, as the individual makes decisions quickly and the discussion is between the shareholder and the board. Not-for-profit boards for commercial people can sometimes be challenging in terms of dynamics and board function, as it can be hard to get agreement on things. ASX-listed boards also operate within market disclosure and investor expectations. Advisory boards can involve broader discussions, giving input from your sector and expertise. For aspiring directors, the question is where your contribution fits, not which board type ranks highest. Ask the right questions, and challenge what management presents In an executive career, you have all the context for the ultimate decision. On a board, you receive a paper with the conclusion but not the full context. Practise suspending judgement, get curious and ask the right questions. One approach is to read each paper and work out the “so what” and the “then what”. Ask what alternatives were considered, which assumptions matter most and what would change the recommendation. Another approach is that a Chair could debrief with the Chief Executive Officer at the end of each meeting on what worked well, which conversations were clear, and which papers did not have a purpose. A board cannot be a team of yes people. Management becomes skilled at stage managing a board, so keep your eyes wide open and call out what doesn’t stack up. That challenge often comes from an industry expert on the board or from outside the company. A board should be governing for where the business is going, not just checking lagging indicators and results. That means holding management to account. It also means contributing to strategy, agreeing risk appetite and tracking forward-looking indicators, while leaving day-to-day execution with management. Directors do not need to be AI experts, but boards need to push the AI agenda The skills that are starting to emerge in the boardroom vary: digital fluency, continuous learning, suspending judgement, curiosity, being open minded and adaptable. On AI specifically, you do not need to be an expert. One approach is to take an AI course to get a better sense of the potential impact, so you can ask better questions in the boardroom and know which experts you need. Boards need to push the AI agenda with management. AI can challenge established roles and business models: it can augment work, improve services and create new value, as well as automate tasks and change workforce needs. Boards should ask where AI is already being used, what value is expected, who is accountable and how results will be tested. They should also seek assurance on data privacy, security, reliability and human oversight, and ask how employees and customers will be affected. Management should develop and execute the response within the board’s agreed strategy and risk appetite. _________________________________________________________________________ Our thanks to Michelle Gardiner , Managing Partner – Board practice at Derwent, for hosting the morning, and to John and Caroline for sharing their experience so openly. A special thanks to Julie Colvin , Managing Partner – Perth, and our Perth team for their support in bringing this event to life. Continue the conversation For further insights or to explore how Derwent can support your organisation's approach to board composition, connect with our team at perth@derwentsearch.com.au . To register your interest in future Derwent events, please reach out to us at events@derwentsearch.com.au .